Meeting20130522

OSLC Core Meeting May 22, 2013

Previous meeting

Meeting logistics

Included in Meetings

Agenda

Review Minutes from April 10

PerfMon 2.0 and part of Metrics declared final

OASIS Board approves creation of OSLC Member Section http://oasis-oslc.org

OSLC Core V2 Issues - Outstanding issues and proposed updates

• TRS-2 truncation of change log
  • Proposal: Defer issue stating we’d like more experience with Joe’s proposed approach
• TRS-3 TRS spec cutoffEvent property
  • Proposal: Add Jim’s description
• TRS-4 various comments John Arwe
  • A) Proposed: Resource definitions - Steve Speicher 2013-05-20
  • B) Proposed: Other misc comments - Steve Speicher 2013-05-20
• Core-10 (was #42) unknown or unsupported property handling
  • Proposal: Update with language to remove error and add warning header
• Core-18 Proposal for new property oslc:shortId
  • Proposal: add oslc:shortId
• Core-17 Handling of long URIs
  • Review proposed changes
• Core-2 (was #31) Format encoding/charset defaults
  • Proposal: Close with no action, just accepting the web for the way it is

• Core-7 (was #38) Suggested improvements to representations samples

  • Proposal: defer to 3.0

• Call to WG members to close out any issues that appear to be “OPEN”. Think some are complete but paperwork (updating wiki page of issues) hasn’t been completed.

V3 Spec Drafting - OSLCCoreSpecificationsV3

• Updates PATCH support - looking at named graph syntax to support model

  • W3C LDP WG not handling in 1.0, deferring and considering more of a research effort for now.

• Use cases and requirements for vocabulary definitions going forward and a proposal

Next meeting:

• June 5 - propose reschedule to June 12 due to Innovate
• June 19 - conflict (W3C LDP WG)

Open / future topics:

• EdGentry suggested topic: Pickers: with preferred or restricted link types, limiting what can be selected or linked to resource type. SteveS suggests submitting the scenario + some details to either RM (or other appropriate WG) or Core to seed the discussion.

• NickC suggested topic: need to extend the OSLC pickers (and other areas possibly like query) to allow a [configuration] context to be passed, so the provider can show the versions/variants of the resources in that context, and so the resulting link preserves that context.

Minutes

Reviewed Minutes from previous meeting

PerfMon 2.0 and part of Metrics declared final

OASIS Board approves creation of OSLC Member Section http://oasis-oslc.org

Tuan: Recon spec: Issue talking about case-sensitivity

• Arthur: which use XML schema types and URLs are too
• ACTION Tuan: to move on to send scenario to WG

OSLC Core V2 Issues - Outstanding issues and proposed updates

• TRS-2 truncation of change log

  • Proposal: Defer issue stating we’d like more experience with Joe’s proposed approach

  • Resolution: consensus on doing this

  • Discussion around how long it takes to handle rollbacks - some actual performance hits in reindexing.

    • Arthur to raise issue from current spec or needed guidance to help implementers/consumers

• TRS-3 TRS spec cutoffEvent property

  • Proposal: Add Jim’s description
  • Resolution: consensus on adding the words

• TRS-4 various comments John Arwe

  • A) Proposed: Resource definitions - Steve Speicher 2013-05-20
  • B) Proposed: Other misc comments - Steve Speicher 2013-05-20
  • Resolution: consensus to accept Steve’s proposal, Steve yet to figure out right “relegate”

• Core-10 (was #42) unknown or unsupported property handling

  • Proposal: Update with language to remove error and add warning header
  • Resolution: consensus to accept Martin Pain’s proposed modified text to Mike’s original proposal

• Core-18 Proposal for new property oslc:shortId

  • Proposal: add oslc:shortId
  • Resolution: consensus to accept, inserted into Core vocab
  • ACTION: Draft description and details to insert into vocab and Appendix A (Common Props)

• Core-17 Handling of long URIs

  • Review proposed changes
  • ACTION on group to review and come back on it

• Core-2 (was #31) Format encoding/charset defaults

  • Proposal: Close with no action, just accepting the web for the way it is
  • Resolution: consensus to close with taking no action

• Core-7 (was #38) Suggested improvements to representations samples

  • Proposal: defer to 3.0
  • Resolution: agree with deferring to 3.0 and when we update with JSON-LD

• Call to WG members to close out any issues that appear to be “OPEN”. Think some are complete but paperwork (updating wiki page of issues) hasn’t been completed.

V3 Spec Drafting - OSLCCoreSpecificationsV3

• Updates PATCH support - looking at named graph syntax to support model

  • W3C LDP WG not handling in 1.0, deferring and considering more of a research effort for now.

• Use cases and requirements for vocabulary definitions going forward and a proposal

Next meeting:

• June 5 - propose reschedule to June 12 due to Innovate

  • Agreement to move to June 12

• June 19 - conflict (W3C LDP WG)

Attendees

Attendees: SteveSpeicher (chair), SamPadgett, PaulMcMahan, MichaelFiedler, JohnArwe, ArthurRyman, TuanDang, NickCrossley

Regrets: PaulSlauenwhite

Possible Attendees: SteveSpeicher (chair), MichaelFiedler, EdGentry, StevePitschke, DevangParikh, PaulMcMahan, JohnArwe, PaulSlauenwhite, NickCrossley, SamPadgett, SheehanAnderson, SuzetteSamoojh, DonCronin, JimConallen, IanGreen, GrayBachelor, NicholasKruk, DavidHoney, ChristopherLazzaro, SofiaYeung, RainerErsch, AndyBerner, CharlesRankin, MikeLoeffler, ArthurRyman, JulianneBielski, RobertElves, TuanDang