Agenda

Updates on Action Items

• Specification work
  • Example OSLC Defined resources (discovery, requirement, collection)
  • Recent changes- Issue tracking
• Implementation progress - unconfirmed
  • Rational (DOORS, DOORS RP)
  • Tieto is implementing OSLC RM.
• Legal
  • Please complete paperwork at RmSpecificationCovenantV2 in accordance with the OSLC Ts&Cs.

Minutes

Apologies:DominicTulley PaulMcMahan, AndyBerner, DaveJohnson,

Attendees: IanGreen, , NicolasKruk, ScottBosworth, JimConallen, IngridJørgensen, SimonWills, BrendaEllis,

Minutes:

Ingrid: lack of consistency across OSLC providers. Scott: Over time we may need to strengthen this, uniformly across the domain.

Scott: Clarification: Core makes strong statement about RDF/XML and its adoption. Encouraging domain specs to support RDF/XML.

Simon: adding types to names is wrong thing to do. Scott: "no right way" there are tradeoffs - guidance is needed. This is one of the topics for Wed OSLC Core meeting.

Ingrid: Caliber does not have query capability. Her application does not need query at all - delegated picker is enough. Scott: concern that we are becoming lowest common denominator where all things are MAY, not MUST. Jim no query at all severely limits useability. Query is complex - perhaps some subset could be implemented. What should our philosophy be? We are on a slippery slope of requiring "nothing". Jim how about: MUST have one of query or delegated picker. Brenda: shouldn't make decisions based on ease of implemenation for any one tool. Query is "highly desired" but is not a "SHALL". Hard to assess the ramifications.

Providers should be able to document what is non-compliant.

Implementation report from the CM team. Query is dissected.

General discussion about query/MUST. Consensus on MUST for query. Action on Ian to update the specification.

Concern from Ingrid - eg marketing impact.

Simon: query is useful - can we make it incremental. SHOULD then later, a MUST. We could advertise the fact it will become a MUST. Scott - we would regret not having query.

Agreed that query is a MUST.

Agreed that an RM implementation report would be a useful addition to the wiki.

Ingrid - not on calls. Need to resend invites. Action on Ian.

Agreed that Monday PM is good time for all.