Asset Management Specification Issue Tracking

List of general comments or issues against the specification development for the Asset Management domain.

Spec comments being worked (Closure description included after each comment, with prefix CLOSED. If unresolved or spec needs to be updated, it will have a prefix of OPEN )

OSLC-AssetManagement 1.0 Draft spec comments:

AssetMgSpecificationV1

1. CLOSED Section comment applies to - Comment description. (WikiName? of commenter 03/xx/2010)
   • Response Comment or resolution (WikiName? of resolver 03/xx/2010)

AssetMgRestApiV1

1. CLOSED Get Resources - Query syntatx does not seem to provide the capability to included Asset relationship specefic atcivities. (EdwinFreekenhorst - 11 Mar 2010)
   • Response Comment or resolution (GiliMendel 03/11/2010) V1 of the specs. only provides limited query capabilities.... we plan to tackle search next, where we include categories, relationships, tags, with results that denote relevance, available (next drill down) categories / tags etc.
2. CLOSED Get an Artifact media Resource - Not clear what happens if the artifact resources is a URL. I.e. is the return value the URL itself or the content of the page pointed to by the URL. (EdwinFreekenhorst - 11 Mar 2010)
   • Response Comment or resolution (GiliMendel of resolver 03/11/2010) V1 of the spec. does not require caching of referenced resources. ... as we iterate on V2, this can be another property of the artifact property.
3. CLOSED Update an Asset - HTTP response status codes not present for a "locked" asset. I.e. already being updated. (EdwinFreekenhorst - 11 Mar 2010)
   • Response Comment or resolution (GiliMendel of resolver 03/11/2010) OSLC does not deal with implementation's collisions, transactions (e.g., adding a set of artifacts media .... a set of posts ... all or nothing). ... from the spec's point of view it is a put or a get ... atomic. In our implementation of this we tried to get away from "locks" as well, rather, we provide the means to use an update context as to allow a all or nothing kind of a function...

AssetMgResourceDefinitionsV1

1. CLOSED Section comment applies to - Comment description. (WikiName? of commenter 03/xx/2010)
   • Response Comment or resolution (WikiName? of resolver 03/xx/2010)

AssetMgQuerySyntaxV1

1. CLOSED Section comment applies to - Comment description. (WikiName? of commenter 03/xx/2010)
   • Response Comment or resolution (WikiName? of resolver 03/xx/2010)