This wiki is locked. Future workgroup activity and specification development must take place at
our new wiki
. For more information, see
this blog post about the new governance model
and
this post about changes to the website
.
TWiki
>
Main Web
>
MainOslcCommonArchitecture
>
ReportingHome
>
ReportingSpecifications
>
OSLCReportingV1Issues
(revision 2) (raw view)
---+ OSLC Reporting Specification V1 Issues This section captures the issues raised on the [[ReportingSpecifications][Reporting Specification]]: Issues are organized via the specification outline. %TOC% Note: dates below use US format (mm/dd/yyyy) Here's what the states mean: * %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% - indicates that we have no response for the issue yet * %GREEN%RESOLVED%ENDCOLOR% - indicates that we have a response that we believe resolves the issue * CLOSED - issue has been resolved and the resolution has been reviewed by the WG * %PURPLE%TABLED%ENDCOLOR% - indicates that issue will be reconsidered at some later for future version of the specificaiton ---++ Overall 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Overview 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Glossary of Terms 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Interface Sequence Diagram 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Service Provider Resource 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Resource Shape Resource 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Query 1 %GREEN%RESOLVED%ENDCOLOR% In the current OSLC Reporting spec, you have the statement: "An OSLC Service MUST support paging and include oslc:responseInfo as required in the response of a query." However, note that the core spec says "The server MAY return the logical response as sequence of physical responses, referred to as pages."<br />What is the reason for the MUST in the Reporting spec? Do you mean that if a response is paged, it must be done as per the core spec? Or do you mean that the server must really break down a response into pages? If you mean the former, I'm not sure the statement is necessary - all OSLC specs from here on are supposed to be compliant with the core spec, so if paging is performed, that is how it must be done. If you mean the latter, why? What is the maximum size of a reportable response? If a provider decided to page after 100 petabytes, is that compliant? If no maximum size is defined, a client has to handle a response of an arbitrary size, and therefore will be able to handle a response from a provider that does not page.<br />Of course, a provider that does not implement paging might not be able to return a very large query result, so support for paging is recommended - but perhaps a given provider knows it's database is not that large.<br />It seems to me the statement should probably use SHOULD rather than MUST. (TackTong for NickCrossley, 04/28/2010) * *Response* Specification updated from "MUST support paging ....." to "SHOULD support paging....". (TackTong, 04/30/2010) ---++ Resource Representation 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Authentication 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Guidance 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) ---++ Example 1 %RED%OPEN%ENDCOLOR% Description of issue. (TackTong, 04/25/2010) * *Response* Description of resolution. (TackTong, 04/25/2010)
Edit
|
Attach
|
P
rint version
|
H
istory
:
r4
<
r3
<
r2
<
r1
|
B
acklinks
|
V
iew topic
|
Raw edit
|
More topic actions...
Topic revision: r2 - 01 May 2010 - 03:02:41 -
TackTong
Main
Main Web
Create New Topic
Index
Search
Changes
Notifications
RSS Feed
Statistics
Preferences
Webs
Main
Sandbox
TWiki
Български
Cesky
Dansk
Deutsch
English
Español
Français
Italiano
日本語
Nederlands
Polski
Português
Русский
Svenska
简体中文
簡體中文
Copyright � by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Contributions are governed by our
Terms of Use
Ideas, requests, problems regarding this site?
Send feedback