[Oslc-recon] Comments on Recon spec

[Tuan Dang]

>6) #ComputerSystem / Additional Requirements 
>6a) 2nd bullet, crtv_hostid should be crtv:hostid  (replace the '_' with 
':').  vmid missing namespace prefix too? 

typos fixed

>6b) Are bullets 1 & 2 just telling me I need a crtv:hostid ?  what the 
positive and negative of vmid? Likewise for bullets 3&4, do I need vmid? 
Some additional >explanation/samples may help here (directly or 
referenced). 

the use of NOT is defined in the terminlogy section [1]
If you have a resource R1(hostid=a,vmid=11) and a resource 
R2(hostid=a,vmid is not set), you cannot reconcile them based
on the rule (hostid, NOT vmid) since R1 has vmid set. Furthermore, you 
cannot reconcile them based  on the rule (hostid,vmid) since
R2 does not have vmid set.
So, although R1 and R2 have hostid in common, they cannot be reconciled as 
we cannot apply any of the rules listed.



[1] 
http://open-services.net/wiki/reconciliation/OSLC-Reconciliation-Specification-Version-2.0/#Terminology


Thanks ! T

Tuan Dang
Tivoli OSLC governance, OSLC Reconciliation workgroup lead, Tivoli Common 
Data Model
Internet: tdang at us.ibm.com
phone: (919) 224-1242 T/L 687-1242
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://open-services.net/pipermail/oslc-recon_open-services.net/attachments/20130226/12efab5e/attachment-0003.html>