[oslc-core] programmatic selection of creation factories

Thu Jun 3 20:55:29 EDT 2010

Nick,

The Shape has a property, oslc:describes, that refers to the type. The 
type doesn't change between implementations, but the Shape resource could 
since implementations could add properties to the type.

Regards, 
___________________________________________________________________________ 

Arthur Ryman, PhD, DE

Chief Architect, Project and Portfolio Management

IBM Software, Rational

Markham, ON, Canada | Office: 905-413-3077, Cell: 416-939-5063
Twitter | Facebook | YouTube

From:
Nick Edgar/Ottawa/IBM at IBMCA
To:
Jim des Rivieres/Ottawa/IBM at IBMCA
Cc:
oslc-core at open-services.net, David M Johnson <dmjohnso at us.ibm.com>, John 
Wiegand <John_Wiegand at us.ibm.com>, oslc-core-bounces at open-services.net
Date:
05/31/2010 07:53 PM
Subject:
Re: [oslc-core] programmatic selection of creation factories
Sent by:
oslc-core-bounces at open-services.net

+1.  We have this issue with the OSLC Automation spec and prototype, where 
we have queryable collections for plans, results, and contributions. 
Currently our service document includes: 

<oslc:service> 
<oslc:Service> 
<oslc:queryCapability> 
  <oslc:QueryCapability> 
    <dc:title>Automation Plan Query</dc:title> 
    <oslc:label>plansquery</oslc:label> 
    <oslc:queryBase rdf:resource="
https://localhost:9443/jazz/oslc/contexts/_xLlHcBipEd6zruFy5LB2ow/automation/plans
"/> 
    <oslc:shape rdf:resource="
https://localhost:9443/jazz/oslc/automation/shapes/plansquery"/> 
  </oslc:QueryCapability> 
</oslc:queryCapability> 
<oslc:queryCapability> 
  <oslc:QueryCapability> 
    <dc:title>Automation Result Query</dc:title> 
    <oslc:label>resultsquery</oslc:label> 
    <oslc:queryBase rdf:resource="
https://localhost:9443/jazz/oslc/contexts/_xLlHcBipEd6zruFy5LB2ow/automation/results
"/> 
    <oslc:shape rdf:resource="
https://localhost:9443/jazz/oslc/automation/shapes/resultsquery"/> 
  </oslc:QueryCapability> 
</oslc:queryCapability> 
</oslc:Service> 
</oslc:service> 

We don't include the query capability for contributions because it's 
currently a nested collection under the URI for a result, 
e.g. 
https://localhost:9443/jazz/oslc/contexts/_xLlHcBipEd6zruFy5LB2ow/automation/results/
{resultUUID}/contributions 
and we have no way of describing that at top-level.  But that's a separate 
issue. 

Also, our use of oslc:label is probably wrong - it's intended to be a 
short, human-readable label.  However, I would suggest that this indicates 
the implementer thought there should be a machine-readable id. 

Rather than providing a dc:identifier with some value that would have to 
be well known by consumers, perhaps the service could describe the element 
type as a property, similar to rdf:type but describing the type of 
elements in the collection, or produced by the factory. 
e.g. 
<oslc:elementType>http://open-services.net/xmlns/automation/1.0/Plan
</oslc:elementType> 

I don't think it suffices to rely on the shape description.  Clients 
should not have to fetch the shape resource to determine the element type, 
and clients cannot rely on the shape URL since it's 
implementation-specific. 
Or perhaps some subset of the shape could be inlined. 

If there can be more than one query collection / factory for the same 
element type, though, an additional identifier would be needed. 

Nick Edgar 
RTC Build component lead 

From:        Jim des Rivieres/Ottawa/IBM at IBMCA 
To:        Scott Bosworth <bosworth at us.ibm.com>, David M Johnson 
<dmjohnso at us.ibm.com>, Steve K Speicher <sspeiche at us.ibm.com> 
Cc:        oslc-core at open-services.net, John Wiegand 
<John_Wiegand at us.ibm.com> 
Date:        2010/05/31 09:57 AM 
Subject:        [oslc-core] programmatic selection of creation factories 
Sent by:        oslc-core-bounces at open-services.net 

ref: http://open-services.net/bin/view/Main/OSLCCoreSpecDRAFT (r95, May 
27) 

Architecturally, it makes sense for a particular Service to have multiple 
occurrences of creationFactory. Take the example OSLC Blog Service as a 
concrete instance: Blog Entry and Blog Comment each have a 
creationFactory. The CreationFactory inline local resource carries a 
mandatory dc:title that helps a user in choosing among them. However, I 
don't see anything that would allow a programmatic client to make an 
analogous choice. For instance, if my client needs to create a Blog Entry, 

how would it discover which creationFactory to use? 

In general, OSLC domains must support the needs of programmatic clients as 

well as ui clients. Adding a mandatory identifier to CreationFactory would 

do the trick. The identifier could be a URI. Well-known URIs could be 
defined in the OSLC domain spec; i.e., OSLC Blog Service could declare the 

identifiers "http://open-services.net/bogus/blog/createEntry" and "
http://open-services.net/bogus/blog/createComment" for distinguishing its 
primary creation factories. All clients would be told to tolerate and 
ignore entries with identifiers that they do not recognize; this allows 
new identifiers can be introduced at any time without affecting 
programmatic clients. And the mechanism can be opened up to individual 
providers by allowing a provider to define additional provider-specific 
identifiers.

I would make the exact same argument for queryCapability, selectionDialog, 

and creationDialog as for creationFactory. Any OSLC domain that has 
multiple major resource types might decide to provide separate query 
capabilities, pickers, and creation uis for each type. Adding an 
identifier to QueryCapability and Dialog would address the needs of 
programmatic clients.

Regards, 
Jim 

_______________________________________________
Oslc-Core mailing list
Oslc-Core at open-services.net
http://open-services.net/mailman/listinfo/oslc-core_open-services.net
_______________________________________________
Oslc-Core mailing list
Oslc-Core at open-services.net
http://open-services.net/mailman/listinfo/oslc-core_open-services.net